What To Do When Mutual Funds Under Perform

By | March 23, 2017

What To Do When Mutual Funds Under Perform

The lure of high potential returns from investments in Mutual Funds is a popular reason for many investors choosing Mutual Funds to build long-term wealth. This helps them build financial security for the future.

Investing in Mutual Funds is considered safer than investing directly in the stock markets and is invariably more rewarding than investing in traditional investment instruments such as Fixed Deposits and Recurring Deposits.

Additional Reading: Why Mutual Funds Are Better Than Fixed Deposits

However, investors must be prepared to expect a certain degree of volatility in the returns generated by Mutual Funds. This is because some types of Mutual Funds are linked to the equity markets, which may not always generate high returns. There may be a few relatively dry spells for investors too.

But if investors are not ready to wait out the storm and persevere, then that ultimately defeats the purpose of long-term investments in Mutual Funds.

BB Tip: It is a good idea to remain invested in Mutual Funds for the long-term if you want to see consistent returns from your investments.

Don’t panic when Mutual Funds tank

We understand it is normal for investors to hit the panic button when their Mutual Funds’ performance takes a hit because of a bear market. One of the secrets to successful investing is to not panic in case of short-term market fluctuations. We can help you understand what you must ideally do when you find your Mutual Funds are under performing.

We will begin by telling you how you can analyse a Mutual Fund’s performance.

Performance analysis

There are two main stages of wealth creation with investments in Mutual Funds. The first is making regular investments and the second is periodically reviewing your investments at regular intervals. For investing success, investors should not forget to analyse their fund’s performance from time to time.

Keeping an eye on the fund performance helps you to better diversify your investments, to take advantage of market volatility, rather than lose out on a bear market. Realigning your asset allocation on your investments will help minimise the effects of market volatility on your investments.

You can assess your fund’s performance by breaking down the returns generated over the past eight to twelve quarters and benchmarking the returns against the performance of the index.

To assess your Mutual Fund’s performance, you can also compare the performance with that of other funds in the same category.

If your Mutual Fund is underperforming in comparison to the index benchmark once in four to six quarters, you could choose to remain invested instead of pulling out your investment.

However, if the fund has underperformed consistently for more than three to four quarters at a stretch, then your Mutual Fund is definitely an underperformer. It may be in your best interest to exit the fund as soon as possible.

Additional Reading: Rebalance Your Portfolio For Best Returns

What are the possible reasons for an underperforming fund?

Once you notice an underperformance in the Mutual Funds you have invested in, what you must do next is identify the reasons for the underperformance.

Here are a few important reasons for a Mutual Fund’s underperformance.

Change of fund manager

Every Mutual Fund manager has an individual style of managing an investor’s investment portfolio and the larger Mutual Fund’s portfolio. The fund manager’s decisions on asset allocation has a direct impact on the fund’s overall performance.

A change in the manager, therefore, will greatly affect the performance of a fund either positively or negatively, depending on the successive manager’s management style.

Additional Reading: Importance Of A Good Fund Manager

Acquisition or merger of the Mutual Fund

In case the Mutual Fund was acquired by or merged with another Mutual Fund house or another Mutual Fund, investors will notice an impact on the overall performance of the fund.

Such a merger or acquisition will result in a change in the fund manager, leading to a change in the fund’s investment style. A merger or acquisition could also influence investors to stop investing, or exit from the fund completely.

Additional Reading: Remember To Monitor Your Fund When The Fund Manager Changes

Style of management of the fund

The manner in which a Mutual Fund is managed can also be a valid reason for underperformance. Aggressive fund management practices may deliver returns in a bull market, but funds which follow a contrarian investing style or a value investing model could underperform during a rallying market, especially for funds that focus on growth stocks.

Additional Reading: How To Pick Good Mutual Funds

Expense Ratio

Expense ratio is the charge levied on each unit of the fund bought by investors. All Mutual Funds incur different costs in order to manage investments. These costs are charged against the Assets Under Management (AUM).

An expense ratio can vary between 1.25% – 3%. To put it in simple terms, the higher the expense ratio of your Mutual Fund, the lower your returns will be, because the returns on your investment decreases in proportion to the value of the expense ratio. You must choose to invest in Mutual Funds that have no sales load or expense ratio in order to enjoy higher returns.

Additional Reading: Term Of The Week: What’s An Expense Ratio?

How to deal with underperformance

A buy and hold strategy does not always work with Mutual Fund investments. In some investment scenarios, it becomes necessary to exit a fund if there has been a long period of consistently poor performance in terms of the returns generated.

Switch funds

Don’t hesitate to exit an underperforming Mutual Fund if it has recorded poor returns repeatedly over the past three years. Redeem your investments in any sectoral funds because you must keep in mind that sectoral funds take much longer to recover from a market slump.

Hold funds

If, on assessment of your Mutual Fund, you feel that the fund will probably recover and deliver better returns in future, you can choose to remain invested and ride out the rough patch.

If a Mutual Fund is managed by a fund manager who displays insightful, impactful and a largely positive management style, you can be assured that the fund will report positive returns in the long run, even though there may be some intermittent volatility over a short or medium investment term.

Additional Reading: Investment Options For Everyone

Now that you know how to deal with Mutual Fund underperformance, make sure you make an informed decision with your investments.

All information including news articles and blogs published on this website are strictly for general information purpose only. BankBazaar does not provide any warranty about the authenticity and accuracy of such information. BankBazaar will not be held responsible for any loss and/or damage that arises or is incurred by use of such information. Rates and offers as may be applicable at the time of applying for a product may vary from that mentioned above. Please visit www.bankbazaar.com for the latest rates/offers.
Category: Mutual Funds

About Dheeraj Kapoor

BankBazaar is the world's first neutral online marketplace for instant customised rate quotes on Loans, Credit Cards, Insurance and Investment products. Shop for financial products just like you buy everything else now - online.

2 thoughts on “What To Do When Mutual Funds Under Perform

  1. Rishab Ashwat

    your statements are contradictory.
    You say to remain invested if the fund under performs for 4-6 quarters & at the same time you ask us to switch/redeem if the fund is under performs for 3-4 quarters.
    are these statements not contradictory?

    1. Team BankBazaar

      Hi Rishab, Redeeming or switching funds is totally dependent on the investor’s risk appetite. Some investors hold on in the hope that the fund will eventually turn around. Ideally, you should think of getting out of the fund if it has underperformed for more than a year. Cheers, Team BankBazaar.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *